The Safest & Healthiest Crib Mattresses For Your Baby

Last updated on February 20th, 2020 at 09:37 am

Get This Look: ♥ MattressCribDresserCrib SheetsRug

You’ve started preparing the nursery, and perhaps you have all the important nursery furniture in there, including the crib. Now you’ve got to put something in the crib – that’s right! The crib mattress!

So just when you thought all the difficult decisions were done, you discover that there are just about as many crib mattresses as there are cribs! Don’t stress, we’ve got you covered. We took the pleasure of finding the top baby mattress brands and best crib mattresses, and rating them for you in our Safest & Healthiest Crib Mattresses For Your Baby article as follows.

Use the links below ↓ to jump straight to the content you want!

Products Featured

Sealy Crib Mattresses Simmons Beautyrest Mattress

Midnight Slumber Baby Mattress Naturepedic No Compromise

Babyletto Crib Mattresses

Crib Mattress Guide

What Else Do You Need to Buy? Buying a Safe Crib Mattress

Best Baby Mattress Brand Types of Crib Mattresses

Best Crib Mattress Brands to Buy

1. Sealy Mattresses

Sealy is no doubt one of the most popular brand for parents looking to buy a baby bed mattress (View Entire Range Here).

Why? Sealy provide high quality mattresses for infants and are ranked by many parents as the ‘best mattress for baby’. They ensure safety and comfort and present us many toddler bed mattresses at affordable prices. In addition, Sealy baby mattresses offer a waterproof mattress that is extremely necessary for our baby.

The two most popular Sealy baby mattresses which we will delve into are:

Soy Bean (View Here)

♥ Baby Firm (View Here)

View All Sealy Crib Mattresses Here

Because we have had personal experiences with the above two Sealy crib mattresses, we have provided more detail below. For the remaining Sealy baby mattress, view the entire range of Sealy crib mattress by clicking the link above (including the Sealy Ortho Rest crib mattress, Sealy Precious Rest crib/toddler mattress and Sealy Baby Posturepedic crib mattress)

1. Sealy Soybean

If you are a little lazy like me you are probably going to like this (LOL). The Sealy Soybean baby crib mattress is the best Sealy crib mattress because it is stain resistant, hence it makes our work (alot) easier.

Where to Buy? Get Latest Price & Free Shipping Here

♥ Buy in UK? UK Price & Free Shipping

The most appealing thing is that, it is GREENGUARD certified – that basically means it really provides what it says and it’s made from soybean oils from American farms

This baby cot mattress is extra firm and has square corners so it fits ideally in a baby’s crib.

For us personally, our close friend, Julie, recently chose this baby mattress for her second baby and she is really, really pleased (along with thousands of other parents).

2. Sealy Baby Firm

The Sealy baby firm rest crib mattress is the second most popular infant mattress by Sealy. It is a coil mattress with a 204 interwoven steel coil system. It can be used for infants and toddlers in a baby crib or bought as toddler mattresses.

♥ Where to Buy? Free Shipping Here

♥ Buy in UK? UK Price & Free Shipping

This baby mattress has hypoallergenic layers and a side pocket to help cool air circulate within

This baby cot mattress is also GREENGUARD certified and provides a healthier atmosphere for your baby to sleep and play inside the crib. It is also considered one of the best waterproof mattress for kids. Want to know what other parents think? Read more Sealy crib mattress reviews by clicking the links below.

♥ To Buy With: Sealy Waterproof Mattress Cover

3. Simmons Beautyrest

The Beautyrest Beginnings Sleepy Whispers Crib Mattress by Simmons Kids is as natural as any good mattress should be and has sooo many features to talk about.

♥ Where to Buy? Get Latest Price & Free Shipping Here

♥ Buy in UK? UK Price & Free Shipping

It is also water and stain resistant and comes in 2-in-1 design; one side is extra firm for infants and the other is comparatively soft for toddlers

The Simmons baby mattress is a non-toxic baby mattress so those parents who prefer to buy non-toxic baby products, this is their shot. The Simmons Kids Beautyrest mattress is also GREENGUARD certified.

4. Midnight Slumber Little Dreamer

As you might have already guessed from the name, the Midnight Slumber (you can view it here) cot mattress is made of all foam. The cover of this mattress is also waterproof. Both the crib mattress cover and the mattress are both non-toxic. It’s also hypoallergenic and has been treated with Ultra Fresh for antimicrobial purposes, and is easily cleaned up with just a simple, damp sponge.

♥ Where to Buy? Get Latest Price & Free Shipping

♥ Buy in UK? UK Price & Free Shipping

It is made with hospital grade materials and is dust mite and bedbug proof

The above comment is quite the relief because sometimes, things happen and you need to know that your baby is sleeping in a safe environment, and on a safe mattress.

The Midnight Slumber Little Dreamer crib foam mattress has 2 sides; one that is firmer for safe infant sleep and another side that is still firm but softer which is better for a toddler bed.

The square corners and edges are unique to this mattress and help to minimize gaps in the crib which will offer safety and peace of mind for mom and dad. The 5 inch thick mattress adds a certain elegance to the crib and bedding alike. It’s a little pricey but well worth it in my opinion, as I’ve used this for my older child and they love the comfort of the toddler side now.

5. Naturepedic No Compromise

The Naturepedic brand (view it here) has made a name for itself in the area of organic and non-toxic crib mattresses (another mattress that makes the list of organic mattresses for babies). This particular Naturepedic crib mattress, from the ‘No Compromise’ range, is a rather popular crib and toddler mattress in spite of its slightly higher price (in comparison to the ones we’ve mentioned above).

Is it worth the extra price? It sure is, if it fits ok in your budget.

♥ Where to Buy? Free Shipping Here

♥ Buy in UK? UK Price & Free Shipping

The surface of this crib is made of food grade materials and is waterproof and easy to clean

The only reason why we have listed the Naturepedic No Compromise down the list is because we have already listed high quality crib mattresses at more affordable prices to appeal to the average parent, on an average budget.

The Naturepedic organic crib mattress, is one of the most organic crib mattress you’ll ever come across.

While it is one of the most expensive crib and toddler mattress brands out there, it’s also a rather nice one. The baby mattress is made from 100% organic cotton and renewable and it’s hypoallergenic, also featuring a dust mite barrier cover. The edges and sides are made with strong heavy duty rods to prevent any breaking or tearing around the edges.

Although with our Babyletto (seen below), crib mattresses by Naturepedic are easily one of the best organic crib mattresses on the market since they are entirely organic and made of healthy materials. There are absolutely no harmful chemicals.

This crib mattress will fit standard sized cribs and convertible toddler beds.

♥ Where to Buy? Free Shipping Here

♥ Buy in UK? UK Price & Free Shipping


Babyletto is named one of the most admired brands amongst consumers for baby crib mattresses (view entire range here).

Babyletto offers two types of baby sized crib mattresses, I have written about them in detail below:

Coco Core (view here)

Pure Core (view here)

♥ Where to Buy? Free Shipping Here

Babyletto has stood firm in its shoes since the time it was founded and it ensures to serve its consumers the highest quality baby mattress with high standard of safety measures and made from natural and organic compounds

For me personally, because I am one for an all organic nursery, my search for an organic, non-toxic crib mattress had finished when I found the below described super-awesome mattress by Babyletto.

6. Babyletto Coco Core

Who else can offer you a ten year long warranty? Well, Babyletto mattresses are exactly that. This is one of the best organic crib mattress in the our list of top organic mattresses but also tops the list for many parents as the best infant mattress of all time as it’s one of the newest released on the market in 2016-2017.

Where to Buy? Best Price & Free Shipping

♥ Buy in UK? UK Price & Free Shipping

This mattress exceeds Flammability standards without the use of chemical flame retardants

Yes, as you can see, it is a little higher priced than other baby mattresses BUT you don’t have to buy extra waterproof crib mattress covers or anything as each mattress comes with everything you need.

I can tell you from experience that I am still using this mattress to this day. It is nice and soft but firm enough to keep you away from the worst nightmare of SIDS. It also prevents your baby from overheating and you can sleep in peace knowing that your baby is comfortable and having a safe sleep.

The above quoted remark is one of the main reasons why I decided to buy the safest infant mattress and it has proven to be 100% correct.

Here are some other great features about all mattresses by Babyletto. A word of warning, these mattresses are the hottest right now and they are selling out fast, we have parents emailing us to get hold of them because they are in desperate need of them. If you see it in stock above, our recommendation is to grab it because it runs out of stock very fast…

The Babyletto Coco Core range is made from the most natural compounds (see the list top natural and organic crib mattresses) and are the best babyletto crib mattress. It’s made from natural coco coir and is Oeko-tex 100 certified. Each of Babyletto’s baby mattresses are waterproof, breathable, water repellent and are made from plus organic cotton.

♥ Where to Buy? Free Shipping Here

♥ Buy in UK? UK Price & Free Shipping

♥ To Match With: Babyletto Crib Bedding, Sheets, Skirts & More…

7. Babyletto Pure Core

Another cool mattress offered by Babyletto which comes with a water repellent cover, is the Babyletto Pure Core mattress. It has almost all the features like the one above (Babyletto Pure Core with Organic Plush Quilt Cover) except it is a little cheaper than the Coco Core range.

♥ Where to Buy? Best Price & Free Shipping

♥ Buy in UK? UK Price & Free Shipping

Its air cover is Oeko-Tex standard 100 certified that makes it much more reliable as for me this means that this crib mattress has passed strict European regulations for AIR containment and skin contact

♥ To Match With: Babyletto Crib Bedding, Sheets, Skirts & More…

Best Baby Mattress Brand

You really can’t go wrong in choosing any of these baby mattresses, they’re all fantastic choices. Now that I’ve done my part, the decision is up to you.

Because everyone asks what I have personally used, here is my personal opinion. I currently have the Babyletto Pure Core Air mattress and wouldn’t choose otherwise. However, I have used the Naturepedic and Sealy mattresses also.

When it comes to searching the safest and healthiest crib and cot mattresses, many parents look at the ‘brand’, hence we have supplied the crib mattresses according to brand.

Which Brand to Choose and Which Brand is the Best?

Well, there is certainly no rule for deciding which is the top infant mattress as everyone’s requirements are different, but each of these provided are considered the safest crib mattress you can buy.

You can read a lot of crib mattress brands reviews or you can take advice from any experienced Mommy, but at the end of the day, this is our advice based on our experiences and the collective consensus of many many parents.

Yes it’s taken alot of research, time and commitment to get to this list, searching through thousands of products isn’t an easy feat.

Buying a Safe Crib Mattress

Crib-MattressA baby can sleep tight only when they are comfy in their crib, and a parent can sleep peacefully only when their baby is comfortable. Both things are co-related. Trust me, after a long day with a newborn all you want at night is a peaceful sleep for 2-3 hours (after that your baby is going to get hungry again and again).

Well, now the question arises, what is the best mattress for a new born baby?

You will find plenty of brands in the market all claiming to provide ‘the best crib mattress’ for your baby, but it is you who needs to select the most comfortable and secure mattress for the baby crib that you have bought.

If you have any questions, as an experienced Mom of two kids, this list should have helped you out in buying a baby mattress but if you have any questions, leave a comment below.

Also, here is a little more about me so understand where I am coming from when evaluating these products.

My Personal Story

At the time of my first child, I was confused about almost everything when it came to babies and buying the right nursery furniture to decor our baby nursery and buying all other baby gear that I needed.

I chose all baby gear very carefully, but when the second baby was about to come I was experienced enough to provide advice to others. The research I did for my first baby proved quite helpful for the second time around.

Although it made me feel less stressful, I must admit, year after year, technology and products do change, so if you have 1 child already, this crib mattress buying guide is still useful to you, so my recommendation is, you still need an update to ensure you are also considering some new crib mattresses available also.

What Else Do You Need?

Feeling overwhelmed yet?

Don’t worry, we have an easy but comprehensive guide on What to Buy for the Baby Bed.

This guide gives you:

1. Helpful tips on what to look out for

2. What products you need to buy

3. How many of each product you need to buy – do you really think only need 1 set of each?!

TIP: You will find below helpful links to direct you to the matching crib sheets and covers for each brand.

While you’re at it, here is a short version of the guide (view the long version here: Baby Bedding Guide) of what’s needed but don’t forget that you need to buy quite a few other little things for your baby bed at the same time as buying your infant mattress.

These include the all important:Baby-Bedding-Checklist

♥ Waterproof crib mattress covers (2-3 at least) (available here)

♥ Crib mattress pad (available here)

♥ Good quality crib sheets (8-10 sets are needed to keep yourself sane)

♥ Crib bumpers (do you know the safest crib bumpers that you should buy?)

♥ Crib blankets/bedding set

♥ Crib skirt

♥ Finally, a crib….

Want and Organic Crib Mattress? Read Here.

Types of Crib Mattresses

Before you step out in search of the best baby crib mattress, you should know the types of mattresses. There are two types you will find and read about in all the baby mattress reviews..

Foam Crib Mattress

Lightweight and less expensive – if you want to go for a baby mattress that won’t give you backaches when you change the sheets, a foam mattress will probably be the best thing to buy. There are different infant foam mattresses in the market that vary in density level and firmness. The firmer and denser the mattress is, the safer it is for your newborn angel.

Coil Crib Mattress

Heavy weight and real expensive – coil mattresses are usually heavier and expensive. The coil count inside the mattress is important to know though more coils do not mean a more comfortable and firmer mattress for your baby crib. You should not be looking for a cheaper one if you intend to buy an innerspring mattress. While purchasing a coil mattress, the more you pay, the more comfort you and your baby will get.

Helpful Tips

Here we also share some quick tips and what to look for when buying a crib mattress or finding the right baby mattress online.

  1. The best and safest baby crib mattress for your baby is a firm mattress.
  2. As crib mattress sheets need to be washed very often, we recommend finding a baby mattress that is lightweight.
  3. To ensure the uttermost safety for your child, you should try to buy an infant mattress that is made of natural compounds. Buying a 100% natural, organic and non-toxic crib mattress is the best baby crib mattress, however, some people’s budget does not allow this. The infant mattress brands below are the highest rated crib mattress brands.
  4. The baby crib mattress should be well-ventilated so the air can easily circulate and a well-ventilated mattress is also a non-stinky mattress which we preferably need for our babies.
  5. A cot mattress should be waterproof and you should also try to buy a few extra waterproof crib mattress pad or baby mattress cover to ensure the longevity of your crib mattress. We have included the waterproof mattress covers with each brand above.
  6. Don’t forget to check out our Baby Bedding Guide!
Anna About Anna

Hi Moms and Dads, Anna here and welcome. I'm a relatively young mom, in my early 30's and my husband and I have 2 young (and incredibly cheeky) children. With my first child, I was confused about absolutely anything that had 'baby' written on it. I felt flustered and overwhelmed. For some Moms I believe it comes naturally, for others it takes a bit of work and patience, and the latter was me. With my second child, all those first round nervous flusters were gone and I approached everything ease, although I do admit, in between 2 children, baby products and my needs and wants had changed and in the baby/infant world, things change very quick and products that were suggested a few years back are now out of date, recalled or just not suitable no more. So it's not only your little bub that grows; products change and the needs and wants of your baby and you change also.


  1. jane curmin says:

    Hi Anna,

    Since you posted this, Newton came out with a mattress that seems really good. Did you review it?


    • Hi Jane.
      I know, the Newton mattress is a nice one too! I’ve read some good things about it and a couple of people I connect with have purchased it so just need to gather up all their input for an update here. I’ll gather up everything and update shortly.
      Thanks for your input.

  2. Awesome post.

Speak Your Mind